Kommasetzung "On the one hand" & "on the other hand"?

Leider findet man im www die unterschiedlichsten Aussagen darüber, wie denn nun die Kommasetzung bei dem obigen Ausdruck ist. Sind hier vllt Experten abwesend, die mir eine klare und richtige Aussage geben können?

3 Antworten

TheAllisons

09.07.2017, 07:56

Hier gehört kein Komma hin, bei beiden Aussagen nicht.

Bswss

09.07.2017, 12:10

Das kann man so nicht sagen. Selbstverständlich KANN man hinter diesen Wendungen ein Komma setzen. Es ist sogar NORMAL, das zu tun.

http://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/on+the+one+hand

Bswss

Von gutefrage auf Grund seines Wissens auf einem Fachgebiet ausgezeichneter Nutzer

Englisch

09.07.2017, 11:33

Steht "On the one hand" am Anfang eines Satzes, setzt man dahinter ein Komma (wie man das bei adverbialen Bestimmungen am Satzanfang im Englischen meist macht).

"On the other hand" folgt in der Regel als Satzanfang einem PUNKT (nach vorhergehendem Satz). Auch hier setzt man danach in aller Regel ein Komma.

"On the one hand" wird aber - im Gegensatz zur Lehrmeinung vieler deutscher Englischlehrer - oft weggelassen, weil es eigentlich überflüssig ist.

Welux

09.07.2017, 07:59

http://dictionary.cambridge.org/de/worterbuch/englisch/on-the-one-hand-on-the-other-hand

Cambridge Dictionary irrt nicht!

Ähnliche Beiträge

Discussion und Comment das selbe?

Hey,

Ich muss eine Discussion schreiben. Ich frage mich allerdings ob es nicht einfach ein Comment ist ,nur mit einen anderen Namen?

Aufbau vom Comment ist ja wie folgt:

Einleitung

On the on Hand, dann firstly,secondly,thirfly....

But on the other Hand bla bla

Firstly,Secondly,Thirdly

Conclusion

...zum Beitrag

Erörterung Englisch?

Hallo,

Was sind "gute" Wörter für eine englische "Composition"

z.B: on the one hand... on the other hand, firstly , secondly , to sum up...

Und was ist noch Wichtig? Also Absätze und so was

Und gibt es starke Adjektive, die man benutzen kann? (Wir schreiben über Schuluniformen bzw Ferienarbeit)

Danke

...zum Beitrag

Gehobene Grammatik für Englisch?

Hallo zusammen. Ich bräuchte morgen für meine Englisch Arbeit ein bisschen Hilfe. Es gibt nämlich viele Punkte auf "gehobene" Grammtik und Überleitungen. Habt ihr irgendwelche Sätze die man im jeden Aufsatz schreiben kann. Für gehobene Überleitungen gelten z. B. "in conclusion", "all in all", "last but not least", "on one hand...but on the other hand" sowas und von den Zeitformen alles ab 8.Klasse. Vielen Dank im voraus.

...zum Beitrag

[HILFE] in Englisch Stadt beschreiben

Hallo, brauche Hilfe. Kann jemand so nett sein und gucken ob dieser Text einigermaßen (9.klasse) in Ordnung ist.:

Mumbai is one of the most populated cities of the world. It is the largest, richest and fastest city if india

Mumbai's population is divided into two sections. On the one hand, there live the wealthy and well-paid people, on the other hand, many people live there in slums are poor and can even afford to live just a little bungalow.

A big advantage in the city, are the attractions. There you can view the artworks of this unique culture. the culture is in buildings, roads and human recognizable.

However, there are also negative aspects that speak against this city. For example, slums are not a good outlook as a tourist. The poor people, poor children and beggars would adversely affect the tourist.

By and large, is mumbai a very interesting city. As a tourist you will discover there a lot and can learn new things.

Kann mir jemand (wäre nett ;) ) Verbesserungsvorschläge und Fehler beheben.

...zum Beitrag

Schul Uniformen (English Text)

Hi, ich gehe jetzt in die 9te Klasse und habe nächste Woche ne Schularbeit in Englisch. Ich weiß jetzt schon dass wahrscheinlich ein Text über SchulUniformen kommen wird und deshalb habe ich schon mal angefangen zu Üben. Ich habe jetzt einen Text geschrieben und ich bitte euch ihn mir auszubesser, denn ich kenne niemanden der es sonst tun sollte.

HIER DER TEXT:

Many People in Austria ask themself, why Austrias schools don't have school uniforms. A lot of British schools have them. There are much pros and cons for these uniforms: On the one hand, you need more than one uniform and they are often very expensive. Much parent can't afford these clothes. Another bad reason to introduce school uniforms is that you can't show your own style. On the other hand you can't be bullied for your no-designer clothings and you mustn't think about to wear in the morning. My opinion about school uniforms is that these clothings are practically. I hate it to think about what to wear for school furthermore I don't care if other students wear designer clothings or not.

...zum Beitrag

Kann das Bitte jemand korrigieren?

Hello Alex,

How are you? I am fine.

You asked me about online learning at my school and you get an answer.

Our online learning is divided into 2 groups, one group has online lessons and the other group has lessons at school. Every morning we have Klassenrat ( In this lesson we gather and disco how the day will go ). Online learning is very difficult and unmotivated for the students, on the other hand, learning at school is much better. The classes start at 8 a.m. and end at 3 p.m. My opinion on online learning is a bad idea because students learn very little when if there is no online learning, the number of infections ( Covid-19 ) increases that is also a not good thing.

I hope I could help you and that you will like my email.

yours,

...zum Beitrag

Charakterisierung in Englisch!

Schreibe morgen eine Englisch-Klausur in der ich höchstwarscheinlich eine Charakerisierung schreiben muss, doch ich habe keinen Schimmer wie ich es schreiben könnte usw. Könnt ihr mir vllt. ganz kurz den Aufbau erklären.. aber was noch WICHTIGER ist: Ich brauche Konjunktionen etc. womit ich die Satzüberleitungen besser gestalten kann also z.B: on the one hand... but on the other hand .. Halt sowas .. damit es besser klingt. Danke im Vorraus ;-)

...zum Beitrag

Englisch text über handys im unterricht

Stimmt das so? das was ich fett gemacht hab bei dem bin ich mir nicht sicher. Wäre super, wenn ihr mit Tipps geben könntet oder verbessert. Danke :))

On the most schools are cell phones not allowed. But many pupils ignore this. But the teachers hate the one and take away the cell phone. Here are a lot of pro and contra arguments. When the pupil needs help they can phones their parents. On the other hand the cell phones can ring in the period and these distract the other pupils to. I know the periods are often boring and messaging with friends is funny but you should be attentive to receive a good mark in a test. I think the teachers are right but I can´t live without my cell phone on/at school.

...zum Beitrag

Englisch Vorteile und Nachteile vom berphmt sein!

Hey,

also ich habe hier Vor- und Nachteile über das berühmt sein geschrieben auf Englisch. Ich möchte nur das ihr schaut ob es mit der Grammatik und dem Satzbau so passt. Rechtschreibfehler müsst ihm mir nicht sagen :) Danke schon mal im Voraus.

On the one hand it is beautiful to be famous because you have much money and you can afford you everything. Secondly you're in the Center Point and everyone likes you except some. But on the other hand you don't have privacy, they know everything about you. You have to life in fear because there always people who are jealous on you. You don't can go out of the house and go somewhere without that someone recognize you. The magazines perhaps write something about you such as "Oh my good the plastic surgery went wrong" and you have to read it and can't say anything because they are allowed to write something like that. And finaly in most cases famous people access to drugs because they can't withstand the pressure anymore.

Andreeeea

...zum Beitrag

Kann jemand meine kurze Cartoon Beschreibung korrigieren?

Hey Leute, ich hab ein Cartoon Beschrieben. Kann mir jemand vielleicht Tipps zur Beschreibung eines Cartoons geben und meine Fehler korrigieren?

<a href="https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/50/7e/25/507e252f9cf1f8e1c46851e0c2601da2.jpg">https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/50/7e/25/507e252f9cf1f8e1c46851e0c2601da2.jpg</a>

The single cartoon by Randy Glasbergen, taken from the website "www..." shows two persons who are dating for the first time.

On the left hand site of the cartoon is a man sitting on a chair and infront of him is a table. On this table is a open laptop which is standing also infront of him. The man is looking at the laptop. Above him is a speech bubble which says,"...". On the other site of the table is a woman sitting on a chair and holding a mobilephone. She is looking to the mobilephone. Next to her is a full wine glas. Above the woman is a speech bubble which says, "..". In the middle of the table is a candle. The scene is taking place at a restaurant.

The message of the cartoon is that both know eachother from online chats but on the first date they still communicate about technology to eachother because they do not know how to do it in real life.

...zum Beitrag

englischer text so richtig? ( write a discussion )

heey :) ich schreibe morgen eine Englischarbeit und wir müssen eine Diskussion schreiben und da wollte ich fragen wie ihr die hier findet und ob ihr noch Ratschläge oder so hättet

I am going to write about the environmentalism. Lots of people think that they won't go green because they can't save the planet anyway. This adjustment is one of the biggest problems in the world today. So the question is can you save the planet or not? On the on hand you have less work and less problems, when you don't go green. If you don't think about the environment you have a carefree life, because you don't think about the aftereffects. On the other hand you fell better when you do something for the environment. You can help with little things, for example you can turn off the lights and appliances when you don't need or use it. You can do shorter showers too. Some work is funny too, example plant trees with friends. Help even more people so the change to save our planet is higher. After looking at both sides I think its better to go green because the most things to help are not complicated. Its not so difficult to help.

Danke schon mal !

...zum Beitrag

Was bedeutet the grass isn't greener on the other side.?

Hab mal ein Kommentar gelesen und da hat mir jemand gesagt ,, the grass isn't greener on the other side" und das jeder früher oder später das erkennen wird

...zum Beitrag

Ich habe einen Text zu diesem Cartoon geschrieben, jedoch weiß ich nicht ob es genügend ist?

[…]. It is about global warming, which includes both climate change and economic climate, which means that the cartoonist shows a serious and important critical point.

The cartoon is divided into two parts.

in the upper right corner, it says "pick one..." and below it is a cross with the phrase "this green," which refers to a us dollar, a company, and a car. the co2 emissions also come from the company and the car.

It also says "save the economic climate" next to the picture.

on the right, another cross is possible with the same phrase "this green" indicating a natural environment such as a tree and the sun. also, next to it is "save the earth climate".

The cartoon represent the only two options people can choose between, whether they prefer to save the Earth's climate or the economy.

If one chooses one of the two options, the other is still a problem.

So, choosing to "save the climate"

would lead to a lot of economic problems because money, such as dollars, would not be produced because businesses produce a lot of CO2 emissions. This means that people would not have dollars and the UK could not be sovereign and leave the EU. A decision for the earth's climate also means that cars are banned or become more expensive because they cause CO2 emissions, even though so many people need a car.

On the other hand, a decision to "save the economic climate" would damage the entire environment because of all the CO2 emissions.

in my opinion, the cartoonist is successful in presenting the only two options people can choose between, either to save the economy or to save the earth's climate, without making any other choice. it's more a matter of damaging the environment or stopping economic growth, both of which have consequences. so it's difficult to choose one term.

I also appeal the cartoon because it is very difficult to pick for only one of the "Greens" and stay away from the others because i am in fact very depending on e.g. technology.

So for me, the cartoon is a good example because it just shows the serious problem we are in right now.

...zum Beitrag

Cartoon Analyse englisch?

Hey, ich soll ein Cartoon beschreiben und wollte mal fragen, ob es was an meinem Text zu verbessern gibt

The colored cartoon shows two different pictures. The cartoon on the left side shows a man who is wearing green jeans and a green Sweatshirt. He is lying on a big phone while smiling and playing with a crib mobile. Worth mentioning facts are the social media logos on the crib mobile. The cartoon on the right part shows a dialog with three different parts. In the first part of the cartoon you can see two man talking to each other. The man on the left side is wearing a green shirt and the Man on the right side is wearing a blue shirt. What catches your eyes the most are the speech bubbles. The speech bubble above the man on the left side says „..And literally within seconds I got more than to replies!“ And the speech bubble above the man on the right says „And what did they say?“ In the two other parts of the cartoon the two men are just staring at each other. The caption of the picture says „It‘s the experience“

Danke im Voraus!!

...zum Beitrag

Was möchtest Du wissen?

Deine Frage stellen